In Spain's property landscape, usufruct allows one to use and enjoy a property without owning it. While this arrangement is especially common in inheritance and estate planning, sometimes investors come across usufruct properties in listings with discounted prices. That's why understanding what exactly usufruct implies is important for a confident and smart buying decision. In this article, we'll shed light on the definition of usufruct, the difference between it and other types of property arrangements, as well as what it means for property buyers in Spain.
What Is Usufruct in Spain? How Does It Differ From Ownership and Lease?
Usufruct is a legal property right in Spain that gives one person the right to enjoy, use, and benefit from a property owned by another. This is legally a temporary split of ownership rights for a defined timeframe, whether for life or a fixed term. Unlike full ownership, the usufructuary doesn't hold the title. The nuda propiedad, or bare owner, holds the title deed while the usufructuary holds the right to use.
Usufruct is common in cases of inheritance and estate planning. In inheritance, often the surviving spouse gets usufruct rights while the children inherit bare ownership. In estate planning, it can be a family agreement, or owners can sell the property title while continuing to live in the property or profit from it. Usufructs can apply to the total of the property as well as only a part of it.
The main difference between usufruct and lease is that the former is a real right attached to the property, while the latter is a contractual right. Usufruct can be created by law, contract, or will/testament, and leases are agreements made by contract. In usufruct, the person with the right to use does not pay rent to the bare owner and can even earn income from the property.
Usufructuary Rights and Obligations in Spain
Spanish usufruct laws allow many rights to the usufructuary without owning the property. This property right remains intact even when the bare owner changes.
The usufructuary can live in the property or use it for profit, such as leasing the property to others. They can enjoy the gains, whether it's produce from the land, rental income, or economic returns within the usufruct's timeline.
They also have the responsibility of maintaining and eventually returning the property in good condition. During the usufruct, property taxes are also paid by the usufructuary rather than the bare owner.
Limitations of Usufruct in Spain
While usufruct allows significant benefits, there are also certain restrictions for the usufructuary. They cannot sell, make major changes, or obtain a mortgage on the property. If it's a lifetime usufruct, the rights end with the passing away of the usufructuary. After it ends, the bare owner regains full control, which means the property cannot be left for inheritance by the usufructuary.
While the property cannot be sold, the usufruct right itself can be transferred to another party under the same original terms and duration.
Usufruct Tax Implications in Spain
As mentioned earlier, the usufructuary is responsible for the property tax, but there are circumstances where other taxes apply.
If the usufructuary rents the property and earns income, they are also responsible for paying income tax. Residents pay IRPF (Personal Income Tax), while non-residents pay IRNR (Non-Resident Income Tax).
Capital gains tax is triggered when the usufruct right is sold or transferred to a third party or bare owner. It is calculated on the difference between the sale value and the original acquisition value of the usufruct right.
On the other hand, when the right is inherited or gifted, it is subject to Inheritance and Gift Tax (ISD). This does not apply to the purchase of the right.
When Buying a Usufruct Property in Spain Makes Sense and When It Doesn’t
Buying a property with usufruct in Spain can offer financial benefits, particularly for limited budgets. These types of properties usually come with a significant discount due to the ownership limitations. When usufruct ends, full ownership consolidates automatically.
However, for many international investors who want to use or rent the property immediately, this usually isn't practical, as you're just buying the bare ownership. This means that you hold the title but can’t use the property until the usufruct expires. Usufruct property laws ensure the right is maintained even when the bare owner changes, making the usufructuary's position secure. However, this also means you may need to wait for years to actually enjoy your investment.
For investors seeking liquidity or thinking that usufruct and rental agreements are similar, purchasing this type of property may not be ideal. These properties can have a longer timeline than traditional investments to return investment capital.
If you're looking to buy property in Spain for your family home or investment, full ownership gives you better control and stability from day one. While usufruct can be a useful tool in certain situations, for most property buyers, full ownership provides the flexibility, control, and long-term value that make Spanish real estate a solid investment.
Common Questions About Usufruct Rights in Spain
What is Nuda Propiedad in Spain?
Nuda Propiedad means bare owner, who owns the title deed of the property. In the context of usufruct rights, bare owners hold legal ownership but cannot use or profit from the property until the usufruct expires.
Is usufruct temporary or lifetime in Spain?
Usufruct is always temporary, though it can last for the usufructuary's lifetime or a predetermined fixed period
What happens when usufruct ends in Spain?
After usufruct ends, either through expiration of the term or passing away of the usufructuary, the bare owner regains full use rights and becomes the complete owner of the property.
EUR
